Buying a Put-in-Bay Rental: Cite $31,131, Never Average

Most Put-in-Bay listings get marketed as a generic Lake Erie stay. That pitch could describe a dozen other towns, and it wastes what actually sets Village of Put-in-Bay, Ottawa County, Ohio apart. Guests who typed Put-in-Bay are looking for Perry's Victory, downtown boardwalk, Crystal Cave, South Bass Island — not Kelleys Island, and not Port Clinton. 58 active listings sit on this extract. Write the town you can actually walk. Keep the listing specific. A vague water caption loses the booking.

Typical listings here earned about $31,131 last year from 58 active rentals, AirROI trailing twelve months through July 2026. The average night was $462. Occupancy was 36.5 percent. Revenue per available night was $170. Year over year is minus 2.9 percent. Active supply moved 0.0 percent. Do not average in Kelleys Island at $24,370 on 61 listings. That is a different town. Leave Port Clinton as a different market. Do not mix those towns. Treat this as a small sample, not a blended coast.

The three strongest months are August, June, and July. August is the busiest. November is the slowest. Most guests arrive from Columbus, then Cleveland. Typical stay is 3.0 nights, booked about 86 days ahead. Call the village administrator at 419-285-8545. Village Ordinance 1504-25 transient rental registration for 2026. Forms at Town Hall. Township hall at 419-285-2292 is another municipality. Do not invent a fee. AirROI Low is a scrape Maria holds still show up in this sample.

DSCR on Thirty-One Thousand 131

That heading is the useful way to read Put-in-Bay, not a dashboard label. Guests come for Perry's Victory. Say that in the listing. Do not bury it under a generic Lake Erie caption. Do not write Kelleys Island copy onto a Put-in-Bay address. Do not use Port Clinton as if it were this occupancy. Be specific about the walk. A vague caption loses the guest who typed this town. Keep the other town out of the title.

Read more in Put-in-Bay Remote Stays and DIY vs Hire in Put-in-Bay. Typical listings earned about $31,131 last year from 58 active rentals, at $462 a night and 36.5 percent occupancy. August is the busiest month. November is the slowest. Most guests arrive from Columbus. Call the village administrator at 419-285-8545. Village Ordinance 1504-25 transient rental registration for 2026. Forms at Town Hall. Township hall at 419-285-2292 is another municipality. Do not invent a fee. AirROI Low is a scrape

Year over year is minus 2.9 percent. Supply moved 0.0 percent. Keep Port Clinton ($20,757 a year) on its own line. A 22.4-percent share of listings uses a 30-night minimum. That is a stay rule, not occupancy. Photograph Perry's Victory. Confirm the parcel before you advertise. Sales tax can still apply under 30 days. Call the desk. Do not underwrite another town's year.

Do Not Average Kelleys Island Twenty-Four Thousand 370

That heading is the useful way to read Put-in-Bay, not a dashboard label. Guests come for downtown boardwalk. Say that in the listing. Do not bury it under a generic Lake Erie caption. Do not write Kelleys Island copy onto a Put-in-Bay address. Do not use Port Clinton as if it were this occupancy. Be specific about the walk. A vague caption loses the guest who typed this town. Keep the other town out of the title.

Read more in DIY vs Hire in Put-in-Bay and Who Books a Put-in-Bay Rental. Typical listings earned about $31,131 last year from 58 active rentals, at $462 a night and 36.5 percent occupancy. August is the busiest month. November is the slowest. Most guests arrive from Columbus. Call the village administrator at 419-285-8545. Village Ordinance 1504-25 transient rental registration for 2026. Forms at Town Hall. Township hall at 419-285-2292 is another municipality. Do not invent a fee.

Year over year is minus 2.9 percent. Supply moved 0.0 percent. Keep Port Clinton ($20,757 a year) on its own line. A 22.4-percent share of listings uses a 30-night minimum. That is a stay rule, not occupancy. Photograph downtown boardwalk. Confirm the parcel before you advertise. Sales tax can still apply under 30 days. Call the desk. Do not underwrite another town's year.

City Versus Port Clinton Travels With the Parcel

That heading is the useful way to read Put-in-Bay, not a dashboard label. Guests come for Crystal Cave. Say that in the listing. Do not bury it under a generic Lake Erie caption. Do not write Kelleys Island copy onto a Put-in-Bay address. Do not use Port Clinton as if it were this occupancy. Be specific about the walk. A vague caption loses the guest who typed this town. Keep the other town out of the title.

Read more in Who Books a Put-in-Bay Rental and Put-in-Bay Tourism Data. Typical listings earned about $31,131 last year from 58 active rentals, at $462 a night and 36.5 percent occupancy. August is the busiest month. November is the slowest. Most guests arrive from Columbus. Call the village administrator at 419-285-8545. Village Ordinance 1504-25 transient rental registration for 2026. Forms at Town Hall. Township hall at 419-285-2292 is another municipality. Do not invent a fee. AirROI Low is a scrape

Year over year is minus 2.9 percent. Supply moved 0.0 percent. Keep Port Clinton ($20,757 a year) on its own line. A 22.4-percent share of listings uses a 30-night minimum. That is a stay rule, not occupancy. Photograph Crystal Cave. Confirm the parcel before you advertise. Sales tax can still apply under 30 days. Call the desk. Do not underwrite another town's year.

Year Over Year Is Minus Here

That heading is the useful way to read Put-in-Bay, not a dashboard label. Guests come for South Bass Island. Say that in the listing. Do not bury it under a generic Lake Erie caption. Do not write Kelleys Island copy onto a Put-in-Bay address. Do not use Port Clinton as if it were this occupancy. Be specific about the walk. A vague caption loses the guest who typed this town. Keep the other town out of the title.

Read more in Put-in-Bay Tourism Data and Complete Visitor's Guide to Put-in-Bay and Perry's Victory. Typical listings earned about $31,131 last year from 58 active rentals, at $462 a night and 36.5 percent occupancy. August is the busiest month. November is the slowest. Most guests arrive from Columbus. Call the village administrator at 419-285-8545. Village Ordinance 1504-25 transient rental registration for 2026. Forms at Town Hall. Township hall at 419-285-2292 is another municipality. Do not invent a fee.

Year over year is minus 2.9 percent. Supply moved 0.0 percent. Keep Port Clinton ($20,757 a year) on its own line. A 22.4-percent share of listings uses a 30-night minimum. That is a stay rule, not occupancy. Photograph South Bass Island. Confirm the parcel before you advertise. Sales tax can still apply under 30 days. Call the desk. Do not underwrite another town's year.

58 Cards Grew 0 Percent

That heading is the useful way to read Put-in-Bay, not a dashboard label. Guests come for Perry's Victory. Say that in the listing. Do not bury it under a generic Lake Erie caption. Do not write Kelleys Island copy onto a Put-in-Bay address. Do not use Port Clinton as if it were this occupancy. Be specific about the walk. A vague caption loses the guest who typed this town. Keep the other town out of the title.

Read more in Complete Visitor's Guide to Put-in-Bay and Perry's Victory and What It Costs to Start a Legal Put-in-Bay STR Stay. Typical listings earned about $31,131 last year from 58 active rentals, at $462 a night and 36.5 percent occupancy. August is the busiest month. November is the slowest. Most guests arrive from Columbus. Call the village administrator at 419-285-8545. Village Ordinance 1504-25 transient rental registration for 2026. Forms at Town Hall.

Year over year is minus 2.9 percent. Supply moved 0.0 percent. Keep Port Clinton ($20,757 a year) on its own line. A 22.4-percent share of listings uses a 30-night minimum. That is a stay rule, not occupancy. Photograph Perry's Victory. Confirm the parcel before you advertise. Sales tax can still apply under 30 days. Call the desk. Do not underwrite another town's year.

Watch-Year Honesty Travels With the Deed

That heading is the useful way to read Put-in-Bay, not a dashboard label. Guests come for downtown boardwalk. Say that in the listing. Do not bury it under a generic Lake Erie caption. Do not write Kelleys Island copy onto a Put-in-Bay address. Do not use Port Clinton as if it were this occupancy. Be specific about the walk. A vague caption loses the guest who typed this town. Keep the other town out of the title.

Read more in What It Costs to Start a Legal Put-in-Bay STR Stay and Put-in-Bay STR Report 2026. Typical listings earned about $31,131 last year from 58 active rentals, at $462 a night and 36.5 percent occupancy. August is the busiest month. November is the slowest. Most guests arrive from Columbus. Call the village administrator at 419-285-8545. Village Ordinance 1504-25 transient rental registration for 2026. Forms at Town Hall. Township hall at 419-285-2292 is another municipality.

Year over year is minus 2.9 percent. Supply moved 0.0 percent. Keep Port Clinton ($20,757 a year) on its own line. A 22.4-percent share of listings uses a 30-night minimum. That is a stay rule, not occupancy. Photograph downtown boardwalk. Confirm the parcel before you advertise. Sales tax can still apply under 30 days. Call the desk. Do not underwrite another town's year.

License Travels With a New City Deed

That heading is the useful way to read Put-in-Bay, not a dashboard label. Guests come for Crystal Cave. Say that in the listing. Do not bury it under a generic Lake Erie caption. Do not write Kelleys Island copy onto a Put-in-Bay address. Do not use Port Clinton as if it were this occupancy. Be specific about the walk. A vague caption loses the guest who typed this town. Keep the other town out of the title.

Read more in Put-in-Bay STR Report 2026 and Market a Put-in-Bay Stay. Typical listings earned about $31,131 last year from 58 active rentals, at $462 a night and 36.5 percent occupancy. August is the busiest month. November is the slowest. Most guests arrive from Columbus. Call the village administrator at 419-285-8545. Village Ordinance 1504-25 transient rental registration for 2026. Forms at Town Hall. Township hall at 419-285-2292 is another municipality. Do not invent a fee. AirROI Low is a scrape

Year over year is minus 2.9 percent. Supply moved 0.0 percent. Keep Port Clinton ($20,757 a year) on its own line. A 22.4-percent share of listings uses a 30-night minimum. That is a stay rule, not occupancy. Photograph Crystal Cave. Confirm the parcel before you advertise. Sales tax can still apply under 30 days. Call the desk. Do not underwrite another town's year.

What a Buyer Packet Should Carry

That heading is the useful way to read Put-in-Bay, not a dashboard label. Guests come for South Bass Island. Say that in the listing. Do not bury it under a generic Lake Erie caption. Do not write Kelleys Island copy onto a Put-in-Bay address. Do not use Port Clinton as if it were this occupancy. Be specific about the walk. A vague caption loses the guest who typed this town. Keep the other town out of the title.

Read more in Market a Put-in-Bay Stay and Put-in-Bay STR Rules. Typical listings earned about $31,131 last year from 58 active rentals, at $462 a night and 36.5 percent occupancy. August is the busiest month. November is the slowest. Most guests arrive from Columbus. Call the village administrator at 419-285-8545. Village Ordinance 1504-25 transient rental registration for 2026. Forms at Town Hall. Township hall at 419-285-2292 is another municipality. Do not invent a fee. AirROI Low is a scrape

Year over year is minus 2.9 percent. Supply moved 0.0 percent. Keep Port Clinton ($20,757 a year) on its own line. A 22.4-percent share of listings uses a 30-night minimum. That is a stay rule, not occupancy. Photograph South Bass Island. Confirm the parcel before you advertise. Sales tax can still apply under 30 days. Call the desk. Do not underwrite another town's year.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a typical Put-in-Bay STR year on this extract?

AirROI lists about $31,131 from 58 listings for August 2025 through July 2026, updated 2026-08-08. Average night $462. Occupancy 36.5 percent. Year over year is minus 2.9 percent. Do not average Kelleys Island $24,370. Do not use Port Clinton $20,757 as this town.

Can I average Kelleys Island into this year?

No. Kelleys Island published $24,370 from 61 listings. Those desks do not cancel into one Lake Erie year. Cite $31,131 from 58 Put-in-Bay listings only.

Which months are strongest in Put-in-Bay?

The three strongest months are August, June, and July. August is the busiest. November is the slowest. Occupancy for the year is 36.5 percent. Typical year is $31,131 from 58 listings.

Where do guests come from?

Columbus is first, then Cleveland. Typical stay is 3.0 nights, booked about 86 days ahead. Superhost share is 79.3 percent. Occupancy here is 36.5 percent. Typical year is $31,131.

Does a low-regulation label mean there is no local permit?

No. That label is a scrape. The live stack is Call the village administrator at 419-285-8545. Village Ordinance 1504-25 transient rental registration for 2026. Forms at Town Hall. Township hall at 419-285-2292 is another municipality. Do not invent a fee. Kelleys Island is another town. Port Clinton is another market. Cite $31,131 from 58 listings.

Is a 30-night minimum the same as occupancy?

No. 22.4 percent of listings (13 of them) set a 30-night minimum. Those numbers are not the same. Typical stay is 3.0 nights.

What should a buyer packet carry?

Cite $31,131 from 58 listings, strongest months August June July, slowest month November, origin Columbus, stay 3.0, lead 86, and Call the village administrator at 419-285-8545. Label Kelleys Island $24,370. Label Port Clinton $20,757. Do not average those years.

Is Port Clinton the same market as Put-in-Bay?

No. Port Clinton published $20,757 from 215 listings. Keep that on its own line. Put-in-Bay is $31,131 from 58 listings, with November as the slowest month. Confirm current rules directly before marketing another town's numbers as this stay.

Related Reading

More PLACE, STATE reading already live on Crest & Cove.

• Put-in-Bay STR Report 2026: $31,131, Not a Port Clinton Mash

• What It Costs to Start a Legal Put-in-Bay STR Stay

• Market a Put-in-Bay Stay: Lake Erie, Not Costume Copy

Work with Crest & Cove Creative

Put-in-Bay listings marketed with Port Clinton's numbers or crowd sell the wrong stay to the wrong guest. That mismatch shows up in bookings, not just the spreadsheet.

Send the parcel before the listing goes live, and we will build Put-in-Bay copy from Put-in-Bay's own $31,131 extract, not Kelleys Island's.

Reach out at crestcove.co or (256) 998-7502.