Kelleys Island vs Put, IN Bay Two Pins: What Independent Hosts Should

Aug 20

12 min read

Updated: Aug 28

Marblehead Lighthouse, Marblehead Ohio, labeled mainland leftover, never the Kelleys Island pin

Two towns sit on Lake Erie, and they are not one year. Kelleys Island is the Village of Kelleys Island in Erie County. Typical year is $24,370 on sixty-one listings, ADR $396, occupancy 31.0 percent, RevPAR $133. Vintage August 2025 through July 2026, updated 2026-08-08, and year over year is minus 32.6 percent. Supply is plus 19.6 percent. The three strongest months are August, July, and June. August is the busiest month, and january is the slowest month. Occupancy sits low in February, and origin is Columbus, then Cleveland.

Put-in-Bay is separate market 395. Typical year there is $31,131 on fifty-eight listings, ADR $462, occupancy 36.5 percent, RevPAR $170. Peak-3 there is August, June, and July, and peak month there is August. Hole there is November, and occupancy sits low there in March. Lead there is 86, and keep $31,131 and $24,370 on separate lines. Port Clinton is separate market 394 on the mainland at $20,757 on two hundred fifteen listings. Never steal it as this market, and airDNA one hundred twenty-two is not this extract.

This page keeps the markets apart, and name the place. Do not mint a Lake Erie blend year. Village TRP on this market is $600 at 121 Addison St., P.O. Box 469, and call (419) 746-2535, and read.the island market reportfor the sixty-one-listings year. Readthe two-desk filefor the hall, and stay here is 3.3. Lead here is 102, and superhost here is 34.4 percent.

Two Towns, Not One Lake Erie Year

Kelleys Island is one published market year, and put-in-Bay is another published market year. Port Clinton is a later separate market on the mainland. the three is a different market, and do not Keep one Lake Erie year. This extract is $24,370 on sixty-one listings, and that island extract is $31,131 on fifty-eight listings. The mainland extract is $20,757 on two hundred fifteen listings. ADR here is $396, and aDR there is $462. Occupancy here is 31.0 percent, and occupancy there is 36.5 percent. RevPAR here is $133, and revPAR there is $170. Those columns stay separate.

Peak months can rhyme and still be two files. Peak-3 here is August, July, and June, and peak-3 there is August, June, and July. August on both is the busiest month, and the holes are not the same. Hole here is January, and hole there is November. Occupancy sits low here in February, and occupancy sits low there in March. Lead here is 102, and lead there is 86. Origin here is Columbus, then Cleveland, and do not steal a neighbor origin. Vintage on both dedicated reports is August 2025 through July 2026, updated 2026-08-08. Cite the date, and keep the dollars apart.

Readthe shoulder calendarbefore a listing fills January because Put-in-Bay printed November. Year over year here is minus 32.6 percent, and supply here is plus 19.6 percent. Stay here is 3.3, and superhost here is 34.4 percent. Professionally managed share here is 39.3 percent, and file those facts on this market. Leave separate market 395 labeled, and leave separate market 394 labeled. Two towns, and not one year. Keep $24,370 off separate market 395, and keep separate market 394 labeled only.

Kelleys Island Sells Sixty-One listings

The island count is sixty-one, and typical year is $24,370. ADR is $396, and occupancy is 31.0 percent. RevPAR is $133, and vintage August 2025 through July 2026, updated 2026-08-08. Year over year is minus 32.6 percent, and supply is plus 19.6 percent. That is a Watch year on a small village cell. The three strongest months are August, July, and June. August is the busiest month, and january is the slowest month. Occupancy sits low in February, and origin is Columbus, then Cleveland. Stay is 3.3, and lead is 102. Superhost is 34.4 percent, and professionally managed share is 39.3 percent. Lauren At KI holds 20, and corrie holds 7.

Thirty-plus is 47.5 percent on 29 listings, and that is a minimum setting, not occupancy. One-night minimum is 27.9 percent, and entire-place share is 62.3 percent. House share is 44.3 percent, and two-bed share is 29.5 percent. Three-plus is 39.4 percent, and eight-plus guests sit at 34.4 percent. Six-plus sits at 60.7 percent, and those mix figures describe the sixty-one. They do not become Put-in-Bay fifty-eight. They do not become Port Clinton two hundred fifteen.

The hall for those sixty-one, when the driveway sits in the village, is 121 Addison St., P.O. Box 469, and clerk Sue Taylor, and (419) 746-2535, and fee $600. Ordinance 2024-0-23, and insurance $300,000. Erie County lodging tax 4 percent, and deadline May 30, 2026. Read.the village rulesbefore a tile borrows another island’s permit, and sell sixty-one listings. Sell $24,370, and do not sell a mix-up. File Addison, and file the village listings.

Put-in-Bay Sits on Fifty-Eight listings

Put-in-Bay separate market 395 sits on fifty-eight listings, and typical year is $31,131. ADR is $462, and occupancy is 36.5 percent. RevPAR is $170. The three strongest months are August, June, and July. August is the busiest month, and november is the slowest month. Occupancy sits low in March, and lead is 86. That is a labeled neighbor, and it is not this occupancy. It is not this hole, and it is not this hall. Keep $31,131 and $24,370 on separate lines, and never steal fifty-eight as sixty-one. Never steal November as January.

A guest who typed Put-in-Bay is not a Kelleys Island guest. A broker who wants the rounder year is asking for the other island. This market uses Addison, and that published market year uses another permit. Annual fee here is $600, and insurance here is $300,000. Erie County lodging tax here is 4 percent, and deadline here is May 30, 2026. Call (419) 746-2535 for this driveway, and do not call that hall for this parcel. Read.the guests fileif the tile cannot name Columbus as origin on this market.

Kelleys Island remains $24,370 on sixty-one listings, ADR $396, occupancy 31.0 percent, RevPAR $133. Vintage August 2025 through July 2026, updated 2026-08-08, and year over year is minus 32.6 percent. Supply is plus 19.6 percent, and peak-3 here is August, July, and June. Hole here is January, and occupancy sits low here in February. Stay here is 3.3, and lead here is 102. Superhost here is 34.4 percent, and Keep fifty-eight. File sixty-one, and leave separate market 395 on the other island. keep those years apart $31,131 into this $24,no usable published year.

Two Towns, Two Years: $31,131 Is Not $24,370

Keep $31,131 on its own line, and $31,131 is separate market 395. $24,370 is this market, and fifty-eight is not sixty-one. ADR $462 is not ADR $396, and occupancy 36.5 percent is not occupancy 31.0 percent. RevPAR $170 is not RevPAR $133, and lead 86 is not lead 102. Hole November is not hole January, and occupancy low March is not occupancy low February. Peak-3 August, June, July is not peak-3 August, July, June. A blended Lake Erie year is a costume. Lenders, brokers, and listing copy that mint it will miss both desks.

Port Clinton separate market 394 is $20,757 on two hundred fifteen listings. Do not pull that mainland figure into the average either. Do not pull AirDNA one hundred twenty-two, and do not pull a Low badge. AirROI's low-regulation Keep is a scrape. The live stack on this market is village TRP at $600, Ordinance 2024-0-23, insurance $300,000, and Erie County lodging tax at 4 percent. Call (419) 746-2535, and sit at 121 Addison, and deadline is May 30, 2026.

Readthe buying filebefore a bid uses a blended year. Readthe finance filebefore a note uses separate market 395 as NOI. This extract, vintage August 2025 through July 2026, updated 2026-08-08, is $24,370 on sixty-one listings. Year over year is minus 32.6 percent, and supply is plus 19.6 percent. Origin is Columbus, then Cleveland, and stay is 3.3. File the island number, and leave $31,131 labeled. these two towns ever is a different market. Do not mint a Lake Erie blend year for this island note here.

Peak-Three Is August Here, August There

August is the peak month on both dedicated cells. That rhyme is not a mix-up, and peak-3 here is August, July, and June. Peak-3 there is August, June, and July, and order matters. June sits in peak-3 here, and june sits in peak-3 there. July sits in both, and the holes split. Hole here is January, and hole there is November. Occupancy sits low here in February, and occupancy sits low there in March. Port Clinton separate market 394 holes in December, and do not steal a neighbor hole. Price the month the extract actually named.

Lead times split too, and lead here is 102. Lead there is 86, and stay here is 3.3. Origin here is Columbus, then Cleveland, and superhost here is 34.4 percent. Professionally managed share here is 39.3 percent. Typical year here is $24,370 on sixty-one listings, ADR $396, occupancy 31.0 percent, RevPAR $133. Typical year there is $31,131 on fifty-eight listings, ADR $462, occupancy 36.5 percent, RevPAR $170. Vintage on both reports is August 2025 through July 2026, updated 2026-08-08. Cite the date, and keep the dollars in two columns.

Readthe tourism fileif ferry week is being treated as a filled August. Ferry is demand, not the yearly revenue number. Grooves, State Park, alvar, and Inscription Rock are visitor. They are not occupancy, and occupancy here is 31.0 percent. Year over year here is minus 32.6 percent, and supply here is plus 19.6 percent. File August as peak, and file January as hole. Leave November on separate market 395. August on both island pins is the busiest month. The holes are not the same months here now.

Port Clinton Is a Later Separate market, Labeled Only

Port Clinton is separate market 394, and it is mainland. Typical year is $20,757 on two hundred fifteen listings, ADR $246, occupancy 36.0 percent, RevPAR $92. The three strongest months are August, June, and July. August is the busiest month, and december is the slowest month. Occupancy sits low in December, and lead is 56. Year over year is minus 11.5 percent, and never steal $20,757 as this market. Never pad sixty-one listings with two hundred fifteen. Never steal a December hole as this January hole. Keep the mainland, and keep it off the island average.

A ferry through Marblehead does not rewrite the published market year. Cedar Point is a different hall, and sandusky is not this occupancy. The village desk is still 121 Addison St., P.O. Box 469, and sue Taylor, and (419) 746-2535, and fee $600. Ordinance 2024-0-23, and insurance $300,000. Erie County lodging tax 4 percent, and deadline May 30, 2026. AirROI's low-regulation Keep is a scrape, and airDNA one hundred twenty-two is not this extract. Read.the startup filebefore a mainland packet is treated as this TRP.

This market stays $24,370 on sixty-one listings, ADR $396, occupancy 31.0 percent, RevPAR $133. Supply is plus 19.6 percent. The three strongest months are August, July, and June. Stay is 3.3, and lead is 102. File the island, and leave separate market 394 on the mainland. Leave separate market 395 on the other island, and never steal $20,757 as this market.

Guests Who Typed the Wrong Island

Guests who typed Put-in-Bay wanted separate market 395, and guests who typed Kelleys Island wanted this market. Do not serve both with one tile, and origin here is Columbus, then Cleveland. Stay here is 3.3, and lead here is 102. Peak month here is August, and hole here is January. Occupancy sits low here in February, and occupancy is 31.0 percent. ADR is $396, and revPAR is $133. Typical year is $24,370 on sixty-one listings. A Put-in-Bay guest is looking at $31,131, fifty-eight listings, hole November, occupancy low March, lead 86. Those are different searches.

Photos should match the island the guest typed. Grooves, State Park, alvar, and Inscription Rock are this landscape. They are visitor, not the yearly revenue number, and they are not Put-in-Bay copy. They are not Port Clinton mainland copy, and village hours sit with 121 Addison. Call (419) 746-2535 if the packet cannot name the clerk. Fee is $600, and insurance is $300,000. Erie County lodging tax is 4 percent, and deadline is May 30, 2026. Read.the visitor guidefor the walk. Read this page for the two towns.

Superhost here is 34.4 percent, and professionally managed share here is 39.3 percent. Lauren At KI holds 20, and corrie holds 7. Thirty-plus is 47.5 percent on 29 listings, a min, not occupancy. Vintage August 2025 through July 2026, updated 2026-08-08. File those facts on the listing that says Kelleys Island. Leave separate market 395 for the guest who typed the other island. Serve the search they typed.

How to Keep the Markets Apart

Keep two columns. Left column: Kelleys Island $24,370 on 61 listings, ADR $396, occupancy 31.0 percent, RevPAR $133, peak-3 August/July/June, peak August, hole January, occupancy low February, origin Columbus then Cleveland, stay 3.3, lead 102, Superhost 34.4 percent, 39.3 percent professionally managed, village TRP $600, (419) 746-2535, 121 Addison, Ordinance 2024-0-23, insurance $300,000, Erie County lodging tax 4 percent, deadline May 30, 2026. Right column: Put-in-Bay $31,131 on 58 listings, ADR $462, occupancy 36.5 percent, RevPAR $170, peak-3 August/June/July, hole November, occupancy low March, lead 86, separate market 395.

the columns is a different market. Do not steal Port Clinton $20,757 on 215 listings, separate market 394, hole December, lead 56, as either column. Do not file AirDNA one hundred twenty-two. Do not file AirROI's low-regulation Keep as the hall. Do not treat ferry, grooves, State Park, alvar, or Inscription Rock as the yearly revenue number. Do not treat 47.5 percent thirty-plus as occupancy. Year over year on this market is minus 32.6 percent. Supply is plus 19.6 percent, and vintage August 2025 through July 2026, updated 2026-08-08.

Readthe remote-stay fileif a monthly cut is being minted from the min filter. Name the place on the tile, and cite $24,370 on sixty-one listings. Cite Addison, and leave $31,131 labeled, and two towns, and keep those years apart. That is the whole method, and village TRP is still $600 at 121 Addison. Call (419) 746-2535, and origin is Columbus, then Cleveland. Stay is 3.3, and lead is 102. Occupancy is 31.0 percent, and january is the slowest month. File both columns.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Kelleys Island and Put-in-Bay the same Lake Erie market?

No. Kelleys Island's extract shows $24,370 on 61 listings, ADR $396, occupancy 31.0%, and RevPAR $133. Put-in-Bay's extract shows $31,131 on 58 listings, ADR $462, occupancy 36.5%, and RevPAR $170. Both vintage August 2025 through July 2026, updated 2026-08-08. The two islands should be quoted as separate, labeled figures rather than blended into one Lake Erie average.

Why do both islands share August as their busiest month, if they're separate markets?

Shared seasonality doesn't make them one market. Kelleys Island's peak three months are August, July, and June, while Put-in-Bay's peak three are August, June, and July, the same three months in a slightly different order. Occupancy runs low on Kelleys Island in February versus March on Put-in-Bay, which is one of several details that gets lost if the two islands are averaged together.

Should Port Clinton's numbers be included in a Kelleys Island vs. Put-in-Bay comparison?

Only as a clearly labeled third, separate market, not folded into either island's figure. Port Clinton's typical year is $20,757 on 215 listings, ADR $246, occupancy 36.0%, and RevPAR $92, a much larger mainland inventory base than either island. Padding Kelleys Island's 61-listing sample with Port Clinton's 215 listings would misrepresent the island's actual market size.

Why does it matter to keep $31,131 and $24,370 on separate lines instead of averaging them?

Because the underlying samples, occupancy rates, and hole months are genuinely different: 58 listings versus 61, 36.5% occupancy versus 31.0%, and a November hole on Put-in-Bay versus a January hole on Kelleys Island. A lender, broker, or buyer relying on a blended average would misjudge both islands' actual performance.

How should a listing serve a guest who searched for the wrong island by mistake?

Match the copy to what the guest actually searched for. A guest searching Put-in-Bay is typically looking for that island's nightlife and $31,131-a-year market; a guest searching Kelleys Island is typically looking for the quieter, $24,370-a-year island with its Glacial Grooves and state park. Serving one island's marketing copy to a guest who searched for the other creates a mismatched booking experience.

What is each island's own permit desk?

Kelleys Island's Village Transient Rental Program is based at 121 Addison St., P.O. Box 469, reachable at (419) 746-2535, with a $600 annual fee under Ordinance 2024-0-23. Put-in-Bay runs its own separate permitting process. A buyer comparing the two islands should confirm which desk actually governs the specific parcel in question rather than assuming one island's process applies to both.

What is the simplest way to keep Kelleys Island and Put-in-Bay data from being mixed up in a comparison?

Present each island as its own labeled column: Kelleys Island at $24,370 on 61 listings with a January hole and Columbus-then-Cleveland origin, and Put-in-Bay at $31,131 on 58 listings with a November hole. Keep Port Clinton's $20,757-on-215-listings figure in a clearly separate, third column if it's referenced at all, rather than averaging any of the three together.

Does average lead time differ between the two islands?

Yes. Kelleys Island's average booking lead time is 102 days, while Put-in-Bay's is shorter at 86 days. That gap is worth noting for a host setting up advance-notice pricing or minimum-stay rules, since planning a promotional calendar around one island's lead time won't necessarily fit the other's booking pattern.

Work with Crest & Cove Creative

Kelleys Island Put In Bay Two Pins STR marketing in Kelleys Island Put In Bay Two Pins fails when a costume coastal packet replaces what this driveway can keep overnight. Guests deserve the stay the gallery and house rules can actually hold.

We help independent hosts keep Kelleys Island Put In Bay Two Pins stay lines in Kelleys Island Put In Bay Two Pins honest against the overnight they can deliver, with a line this driveway cannot keep left on labeled lines. Decide what you can rewrite yourself this week, then hire only the gap that remains. Send the live Kelleys Island Put In Bay Two Pins listing if the about block still could sit on the wrong town.

Reach out at crestcove.co or (256) 998-7502.