Kelleys Island and the Grooves: Guest Stops Hosts Can Actually Promise
Updated: Aug 28
Kelleys Island, Ohio, published a typical year of $24,370 on 61 listings for the August 2025 through July 2026 vintage, updated 2026-08-08. ADR is $396. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. RevPAR is $133. Year over year is minus 32.6 percent. Supply grew 19.6 percent. The three strongest months are August, July, and June. August is the busiest month. January is the slowest month. Occupancy is at its lowest in February. Origin is Columbus, then Cleveland. Write the island the guest can walk. Do not write a mix-uped Put-in-Bay stay.
The pin is the Village of Kelleys Island, Erie County. Glacial Grooves. State Park. North Shore Alvar. Inscription Rock. Village ferry from Marblehead. Stay is 3.3 nights. Lead is 102 days. Superhost share is 34.4 percent. Professionally managed share is 39.3 percent. Entire homes are 62.3 percent. Houses are 44.3 percent. Eight-plus capacity is 34.4 percent. Six-plus is 60.7 percent. Confirm village hours. Confirm park hours. Leave out unverified those hours.
Put-in-Bay is $31,131 on 58 listings as a labeled separate market. Port Clinton is $20,757 on 215 listings as mainland. Never average those years. Never treat this walk as South Bass. Leave AirDNA one hundred twenty-two off the guest guide. Cite $24,370. Year over year is minus 32.6 percent. Supply grew 19.6 percent. Treat this as a watch-sized sample. Cite 61 listings. Name the ferry as a stop. Name the grooves as landscape. Serve the guest who typed Kelleys Island.
Arrive at the Island on Purpose
Arrive at Kelleys Island on purpose. This market is the Village of Kelleys Island, Erie County. It is not Put-in-Bay. It is not Port Clinton. It is not a generic Erie overnight with an island caption. Typical year is $24,370 on 61 listings. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. ADR is $396. The three strongest months are August, July, and June. August is the busiest month. January is the slowest month. Occupancy is at its lowest in February. Origin is Columbus, then Cleveland. Write those rows. Leave the blend off the arrival.
Village ferry from Marblehead is how many guests arrive. That crossing is demand. It is not the yearly revenue number. Stay is 3.3 nights. Lead is 102 days. Superhost share is 34.4 percent. Professionally managed share is 39.3 percent. Kelleys Island market report still has to publish $24,370 without an arrival. How to market a Kelleys Island stay still has to photograph the walk you can take. Do not paste a Put-in-Bay nightlife caption on the dock.
Year over year is minus 32.6 percent. Supply grew 19.6 percent. Treat this as a watch-sized sample. Entire homes are 62.3 percent. Houses are 44.3 percent. Eight-plus capacity is 34.4 percent. Six-plus is 60.7 percent. Village Transient Rental sits at the published market year for this town. AirROI's low-regulation Keep is a scrape. Live stack is village Transient Rental. Cite $24,370. Cite 61 listings. Cite occupancy 31.0 percent. Arrive on this island. Keep Put-in-Bay $31,131 labeled. Keep Port Clinton $20,757 labeled. Write August as the peak month. Write January as the hole.
Walk the Grooves Before You Promise a Geology Day
Walk the Glacial Grooves before you promise a geology day. Photograph the grooves you can name. Confirm access. Leave out unverified hours. Do not mint occupancy from limestone. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. Typical year is $24,370 on 61 listings. ADR is $396. RevPAR is $133. Grooves are landscape. They are visitor. They are not the yearly revenue number. A guest guide that files groove photos as a filled August is already wrong. Write the walk. Leave $24,370 on the extract.
The three strongest months are August, July, and June. August is the busiest month. January is the slowest month. Occupancy is at its lowest in February. Origin is Columbus, then Cleveland. Stay is 3.3 nights. Lead is 102 days.Tourism datastill has to keep groove headcount off the year. Inscription Rock is visitor too. Alvar is visitor too. Confirm those walks. Do not steal Put-in-Bay November as this hole because the grooves sit quiet in winter. Leave out unverified a winter sport as occupancy.
Entire homes are 62.3 percent. Houses are 44.3 percent. Eight-plus capacity is 34.4 percent. Six-plus is 60.7 percent. Superhost share is 34.4 percent. Professionally managed share is 39.3 percent. Lauren At KI holds 20. Corrie holds 7. Those mixes travel with sixty-one listings. They do not travel with a geology caption. Put-in-Bay is $31,131 on 58 listings, labeled separate market. Port Clinton is $20,757 on 215 listings, labeled separate market. Never average. Cite $24,370. Promise only the walk you can stand on. Cite occupancy 31.0 percent. Cite stay 3.3. Cite lead 102. Photograph groove light you can defend.
Name the Ferry as a Separate Stop
Name the village ferry as a separate stop. It is how a Columbus guest, then a Cleveland guest, reaches this island. It is not occupancy. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. Typical year is $24,370. ADR is $396. 61 listings. A guide that files a boat schedule as the yearly revenue number is already wrong. Write the crossing. Write the year. Keep those desks apart. The three strongest months are August, July, and June. August is the busiest month. January is the slowest month. Occupancy is at its lowest in February. Stay is 3.3 nights. Lead is 102 days.
Put-in-Bay is another island crossing. Port Clinton is mainland. Never steal either occupancy because a boat also sits on that water.Who books a Kelleys Island rentalis still a guest who typed Kelleys Island.Village versus Put-in-Bay desksstill split the halls. Origin is Columbus, then Cleveland. Superhost share is 34.4 percent. Professionally managed share is 39.3 percent. Those rows do not change at the dock.
Year over year is minus 32.6 percent. Supply grew 19.6 percent. Treat this as a watch-sized sample. Entire homes are 62.3 percent. Houses are 44.3 percent. Eight-plus capacity is 34.4 percent. Village Transient Rental is $600 at. Erie County lodging tax is 4 percent. AirROI's low-regulation Keep is a scrape. Leave AirDNA one hundred twenty-two off the ferry paragraph. Cite $24,370. Cite 61 listings. Cite occupancy 31.0 percent. Name the ferry. Keep it off the yearly revenue number. Keep Put-in-Bay labeled. Cite stay 3.3. Cite Columbus origin. Write the crossing as a stop.
Confirm Village Hours Before You Promise Downtown
Confirm village hours before you promise downtown. Leave out unverified those hours. The hall sits at 121 Addison Street. Clerk line is. Village Transient Rental is $600. Ordinance is 2024-0-23. Insurance floor is $300,000. Erie County lodging tax is 4 percent. Deadline is May 30, 2026. AirROI's low-regulation Keep is a scrape. Live stack is village Transient Rental. A guide that files AirROI's low-regulation Keep as open hours is already wrong. Confirm the desk. Confirm the walk.
Typical year is $24,370 on 61 listings. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. ADR is $396. The three strongest months are August, July, and June. August is the busiest month. January is the slowest month. Occupancy is at its lowest in February. Origin is Columbus, then Cleveland. Stay is 3.3 nights. Lead is 102 days.Village STR ruleswalk this map.Startup coststill starts at the village desk. Downtown is the village. It is not Put-in-Bay. It is not Port Clinton.
Superhost share is 34.4 percent. Professionally managed share is 39.3 percent. Entire homes are 62.3 percent. Houses are 44.3 percent. Hotel and boutique listings are 39.3 percent. Eight-plus capacity is 34.4 percent. Year over year is minus 32.6 percent. Supply grew 19.6 percent. Treat this as a watch-sized sample. Cite $24,370. Cite 61 listings. Confirm hours. Leave out unverified a downtown calendar from a separate market island. Keep Put-in-Bay $31,131 labeled. Keep this promise on Kelleys Island. Cite occupancy 31.0 percent. Cite stay 3.3. Confirm the desk before you promise downtown.
Eat in a Town of Sixty-One Listings
Eat in a place of sixty-one listings. That count is this market. Typical year is $24,370. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. ADR is $396. RevPAR is $133. Entire homes are 62.3 percent. Houses are 44.3 percent. Hotel and boutique listings are 39.3 percent. Two-bedrooms are 29.5 percent. Three-plus bedrooms are 39.4 percent. Eight-plus capacity is 34.4 percent. Six-plus is 60.7 percent. Write the house the guest actually booked. Leave out unverified a restaurant brand this extract did not print. Do not paste a Put-in-Bay dining caption on this table.
Stay is 3.3 nights. Lead is 102 days. Origin is Columbus, then Cleveland. The three strongest months are August, July, and June. August is the busiest month. January is the slowest month. Occupancy is at its lowest in February. Superhost share is 34.4 percent. Professionally managed share is 39.3 percent. Lauren At KI holds 20. Corrie holds 7.DIY versus hirestill has to Keep those rows. Sixty-one listings do not mint Put-in-Bay occupancy. Put-in-Bay is 58 listings at $31,131. Port Clinton is 215 listings at $20,757.
Year over year is minus 32.6 percent. Supply grew 19.6 percent. Treat this as a watch-sized sample. One-night stays are 27.9 percent. Thirty-plus is a minimum setting on 29 listings, 47.5 percent, not occupancy. Write the filter. Write the table. Leave AirDNA one hundred twenty-two off the meal. Cite $24,370. Cite 61 listings. Cite occupancy 31.0 percent. Eat on this island. Keep the other halls labeled. Keep visitor wine off the yearly revenue number. Cite stay 3.3. Cite lead 102. Write the house, not a dining caption.
Do Not Treat This as Put-in-Bay
Do not treat this as Put-in-Bay. Put-in-Bay published $31,131 on 58 listings. ADR $462. Occupancy 36.5 percent. RevPAR $170. Peak-3 there is August, June, and July. August is the busiest month. Hole there is November. Occupancy low there is March. Lead there is 86 days. Keep those facts. Typical listings here earned about $24,370 last year from 61 active rentals. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. ADR is $396. Origin here is Columbus, then Cleveland. Stay here is 3.3. Lead here is 102. Hole here is January. Occupancy low here is February.
A guest guide that files Bass Island nightlife as this overnight is already wrong. A gallery that leads with South Bass and a Kelleys driveway is already wrong.Kelleys Island versus Put-in-Bayexists so those identities stay apart. Grooves, ferry, park, and alvar on this island are still visitor. They are still not Put-in-Bay occupancy. They are still not the yearly revenue number. Serve the guest who typed Kelleys Island.
Port Clinton is $20,757 on 215 listings, labeled separate market. Hole there is December. Never steal that mainland walk. Year over year here is minus 32.6 percent. Supply here grew 19.6 percent. Treat this as a watch-sized sample. Entire homes are 62.3 percent. Houses are 44.3 percent. Eight-plus capacity is 34.4 percent. Village Transient Rental remains $600 at. Cite $24,370. Cite 61 listings. Keep Put-in-Bay on the other island. Keep this guide on Kelleys. Cite occupancy 31.0 percent. Cite ADR $396. Cite stay 3.3. Cite lead 102. Serve the guest who typed this island.
Confirm State Park Hours Before You Promise a Beach
Confirm State Park hours before you promise a beach. Leave out unverified those hours. Kelleys Island State Park is visitor. It is not this extract. This extract is $24,370 on 61 listings. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. ADR is $396. Year over year is minus 32.6 percent. Supply grew 19.6 percent. January is the hole. Occupancy is at its lowest in February. A guide that files a winter beach as occupancy is already wrong. Write the park as a stop. Confirm the gate. Leave the yearly revenue number on the extract.
The three strongest months are August, July, and June. August is the busiest month. Origin is Columbus, then Cleveland. Stay is 3.3 nights. Lead is 102 days. Superhost share is 34.4 percent. Professionally managed share is 39.3 percent.Shoulder seasonstill prices the months the extract named.Tourism datastill has to keep park photos off the year. Do not steal Put-in-Bay November as this hole. Do not steal Port Clinton December as this hole.
Entire homes are 62.3 percent. Houses are 44.3 percent. Eight-plus capacity is 34.4 percent. Six-plus is 60.7 percent. Village Transient Rental is $600 at. Erie County lodging is 4 percent. AirROI's low-regulation Keep is a scrape. Put-in-Bay is $31,131 on 58 listings, labeled separate market. Port Clinton is $20,757 on 215 listings, labeled separate market. Never average. Cite $24,370. Cite 61 listings. Confirm the beach. Promise only the hours you have checked. Cite occupancy 31.0 percent. Cite stay 3.3. Cite January as this hole. Keep the beach as visitor.
How to Use this listing Without a Stay
Use this market as Kelleys Island. Typical year $24,370. 61 listings. ADR $396. Occupancy 31.0 percent. RevPAR $133. Year over year minus 32.6 percent. Supply plus 19.6 percent. Peak-3 August, July, June. Peak August. Hole January. Occupancy low February. Origin Columbus, then Cleveland. Stay 3.3. Lead 102. Superhost 34.4 percent. Professionally managed 39.3 percent. Lauren At KI 20. Corrie 7. Those rows are enough. They are this extract. They are not Put-in-Bay. They are not Port Clinton.
Walk the grooves. Name the ferry. Confirm village hours. Confirm park hours. Eat in a place of sixty-one listings. Leave visitor dollars off the yearly revenue number. Remote stays still have to write 30-plus as a minimum setting on 29 listings, 47.5 percent, not occupancy.Village versus Put-in-Bay desksstill split the halls. A stay files November as this hole. A stay files $31,131 as this year. Do not file that stay.
Village Transient Rental remains $600 at. Erie County lodging remains 4 percent. AirROI's low-regulation Keep remains a scrape. Entire homes are 62.3 percent. Houses are 44.3 percent. Eight-plus capacity is 34.4 percent. Six-plus is 60.7 percent. Leave AirDNA one hundred twenty-two off the guide. Keep Put-in-Bay $31,131 on 58 listings. Keep Port Clinton $20,757 on 215 listings. Cite $24,370. Cite 61 listings. Use the island you can walk. Leave the blend off the file. Cite occupancy 31.0 percent. Cite ADR $396. Cite stay 3.3. Cite August as the peak month. Treat this as a watch-sized sample.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do guests actually reach Kelleys Island?
By ferry from Marblehead — the Village of Kelleys Island sits in Erie County and isn't reachable by a direct land route. The ferry crossing is part of the visitor experience itself, worth naming specifically rather than a vague "island getaway" description.
What does Kelleys Island's published typical year look like?
About $24,370 in typical annual revenue across 61 listings for the August 2025 through July 2026 period. August, July, and June are the three strongest months; January is the slowest. Most guests come from Columbus, followed by Cleveland.
What are the Glacial Grooves, and how should a listing describe them?
A genuine geological landmark on the island, along with nearby Inscription Rock and the island's alvar habitat — worth naming as specific guest stops. They're a landscape draw, not an occupancy statistic, so describe them as a walk guests can plan, and confirm current access hours before promising a visit.
Should Kelleys Island be marketed using Put-in-Bay's numbers or identity?
No. Put-in-Bay is a separate island market, publishing about $31,131 in typical annual revenue across 58 listings with 36.5 percent occupancy — different figures and a different destination from Kelleys Island's own $24,370 across 61 listings. Keep the two clearly separate in both guest and host-facing copy.
What local fees and taxes apply to a Kelleys Island short-term rental?
A Village Transient Rental registration runs $600, and Erie County lodging tax is 4 percent. Confirm current requirements directly with Village Hall, at 121 Addison Street, before listing or renewing, rather than relying on a figure from an aggregator site.
Is a 30-night minimum-stay setting the same as high occupancy?
No. About 29 listings, or 47.5 percent of the market, set a 30-night-plus minimum, but that's a host-chosen booking filter, not proof of a booked month. It's worth knowing as a competitive signal, but it shouldn't be confused with the market's actual occupancy figures.
How does Kelleys Island compare to mainland Port Clinton?
Port Clinton, on the mainland, publishes about $20,757 in typical annual revenue across 215 listings — a larger, different market from Kelleys Island's island-based 61 listings. Keep the two on separate lines, since guests choosing an island stay specifically want the ferry-access experience Port Clinton doesn't offer.
What kind of dining and lodging should guests expect on a market this small?
With 61 total listings and entire-home stays making up about 62.3 percent of the market, Kelleys Island offers a limited set of local dining options rather than mainland-level variety. Recommend specific, verifiable places rather than implying a wider selection than the island actually supports.
Related Reading
More Kelleys Island, Ohio reading already live on Crest & Cove.
Work with Crest & Cove Creative
Kelleys Island's $24,370 typical year is nowhere near Put-in-Bay's $31,131, yet island guides keep blending the two into one caption. A listing that borrows Put-in-Bay's story is selling the wrong stay to the wrong guest.
We help Kelleys Island hosts write listing copy around the Marblehead ferry, Glacial Grooves, and the island's own occupancy pattern instead of a borrowed Put-in-Bay pitch. Send your live listing and we'll flag every mismatched comparison.
Reach out at crestcove.co or (256) 998-7502.
Comments