Who Books a Kelleys Island Rental: Columbus, Not Put-in-Bay
Updated: Aug 28
Kelleys Island, Ohio, published a typical year of $24,370 on 61 listings for the August 2025 through July 2026 vintage, updated 2026-08-08. ADR is $396. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. RevPAR is $133. Year over year is minus 32.6 percent. Supply grew 19.6 percent. The three strongest months are August, July, and June. August is the busiest month. January is the slowest month. Occupancy is at its lowest in February. Origin is Columbus, then Cleveland. Those rows describe the guest who typed Kelleys Island. They do not describe a mix-uped Bass Island overnight.
The pin is the Village of Kelleys Island, Erie County. Glacial Grooves. State Park. North Shore Alvar. Inscription Rock. Village ferry from Marblehead. Stay is 3.3 nights. Lead is 102 days. Superhost share is 34.4 percent. Professionally managed share is 39.3 percent. Eight-plus capacity is 34.4 percent. Six-plus is 60.7 percent. Entire homes are 62.3 percent. Houses are 44.3 percent. Write those mixes. Leave Put-in-Bay nightlife off this tile.
Put-in-Bay is $31,131 on 58 listings as a labeled separate market. Port Clinton is $20,757 on 215 listings as mainland. Never average those years. Never steal either occupancy as this market. Serve the guest who typed Kelleys Island. Name August. Name the grooves. Name the village ferry. Entire homes are 62.3 percent. Houses are 44.3 percent. Eight-plus capacity is 34.4 percent. Leave AirDNA one hundred twenty-two off the guest file. Leave an Erie shore off the gallery.
August Is the Busiest Month
August is the peak month on this market. The three strongest months are August, July, and June. Typical year is $24,370. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. ADR is $396. 61 listings. A guest who typed August on Kelleys Island is not asking for a generic Erie weekend with an island caption. Name August. Photograph August light you can defend. Do not paste a Put-in-Bay August headline on this tile. Do not steal Put-in-Bay June order as this money list if the extract named July second here.
Stay is 3.3 nights. Lead is 102 days. Origin is Columbus, then Cleveland. Superhost share is 34.4 percent. Professionally managed share is 39.3 percent. Lauren At KI holds 20. Corrie holds 7. Those rows travel with the August guest. They do not travel with a mix-uped hall.Kelleys Island market reportstill has to publish August as the peak month.Shoulder seasonstill prices the year the extract named.
Village ferry is demand. Glacial Grooves are landscape. State Park is visitor. Those are not the yearly revenue number. They are not a filled August stolen from Put-in-Bay. Occupancy for the year is 31.0 percent. Year over year is minus 32.6 percent. Supply grew 19.6 percent. Treat this as a watch-sized sample. Write August as the month sixty-one cards actually ran. Leave November off this paragraph. Leave December off this paragraph. Put-in-Bay hole is November. Port Clinton hole is December. This hole is January. Cite $24,370. Cite 61 listings. Cite occupancy 31.0 percent. Keep Put-in-Bay labeled. Write August as the money month.
June Is Still One of the Three Strongest Months
June sits on peak-3 here. The three strongest months are August, July, and June. still August is the busiest month. June is not separate market mud. June is not Put-in-Bay occupancy. Typical year is $24,370 on 61 listings. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. ADR is $396. RevPAR is $133. A guest who typed June on Kelleys Island is asking for this island in a money month the extract named. Write June. Photograph June light you can stand in. Do not dress June as a separate market because Put-in-Bay printed a different order.
Put-in-Bay peak-3 is August, June, and July. That order is theirs. This order is August, July, June. Keep the lists apart. Origin is Columbus, then Cleveland. Stay is 3.3 nights. Lead is 102 days.How to market a Kelleys Island staystill has to photograph the grooves and the village ferry. It does not get to paste a Put-in-Bay June caption as this overnight. Occupancy is at its lowest in February. January is the slowest month. Those rows do not change in June.
Port Clinton peak-3 is August, June, and July on 215 listings. Never steal that mainland list as this market. Never average $20,757 into $24,370 because June sits on both extracts. Eight-plus capacity is 34.4 percent. Six-plus is 60.7 percent. Two-bedrooms are 29.5 percent. Three-plus bedrooms are 39.4 percent. Write the house the June guest actually booked. Leave AirDNA one hundred twenty-two off the June tile. Publish $24,370. Name June as peak-3, not as a peak. Stay 3.3. Lead 102. Watch sample on sixty-one cards.
Most Guests Arrive from Columbus
Columbus is origin on this market. That row is this market. It is not Put-in-Bay. It is not Port Clinton. It is not a fiber promise. A guest who typed Kelleys Island from Columbus is asking for this island. Write Columbus. Photograph the walk that guest can take. Glacial Grooves. Village ferry from Marblehead. State Park. Alvar. Inscription Rock. Those are visitor. They are not occupancy. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. Typical year is $24,370. 61 listings.
Stay is 3.3 nights. Lead is 102 days. The three strongest months are August, July, and June. August is the busiest month. January is the slowest month. Occupancy is at its lowest in February. Superhost share is 34.4 percent. Professionally managed share is 39.3 percent.DIY versus hirestill has to Keep Lauren At KI 20 and Corrie 7 without turning origin into a shop. Columbus origin is who typed the island. It is not a filled month. It is not occupancy. Occupancy is 31.0 percent.
Entire homes are 62.3 percent. Houses are 44.3 percent. Hotel and boutique listings are 39.3 percent. Eight-plus capacity is 34.4 percent. Six-plus is 60.7 percent. Those mixes travel with Columbus origin. They do not travel with a mix-uped Erie year. Put-in-Bay is $31,131 on 58 listings, labeled separate market. Port Clinton is $20,757 on 215 listings, labeled separate market. Never average those years because Columbus also drives that water. Write Columbus as this origin. Leave the other halls labeled. Cite $24,370. Cite occupancy 31.0 percent. Cite stay 3.3. Cite lead 102.
Cleveland Is a Second Origin, Not the Product
Cleveland is the second origin on this market. Second origin is not the product. The product is Kelleys Island. Typical year is $24,370. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. ADR is $396. 61 listings. A listing that writes Cleveland nightlife as this overnight is already wrong. A listing that writes Put-in-Bay as the Cleveland drive is already wrong. Write Cleveland as the second line. Write the island as the stay. Leave Bass Island copy on the other hall.
The three strongest months are August, July, and June. January is the slowest month. Occupancy is at its lowest in February. Stay is 3.3 nights. Lead is 102 days. Origin first line is Columbus. Second line is Cleveland.Tourism datastill has to keep ferry counts off the yearly revenue number.Complete visitor guidestill has to name the grooves. Cleveland guests still need those desks. They do not need a mix-uped shore. They do not need Port Clinton occupancy.
Put-in-Bay lead is 86 days on 58 listings. This lead is 102 days on 61 listings. Those are different files. Occupancy there is 36.5 percent. Occupancy here is 31.0 percent. ADR there is $462. ADR here is $396. Year over year here is minus 32.6 percent. Supply here grew 19.6 percent. Treat this as a watch-sized sample. Write Cleveland as origin two. Do not mint a product from a drive time. Do not steal $31,131 as this year because Cleveland sits on the same lake. Cite $24,370. Cite 61 listings. Cite occupancy 31.0 percent. Keep the second origin on the second line. Keep Kelleys Island as the product.
Eight-Plus Capacity Is Common on Kelleys
Eight-plus capacity is 34.4 percent on this market. Six-plus is 60.7 percent. Three-plus bedrooms are 39.4 percent. Two-bedrooms are 29.5 percent. Entire homes are 62.3 percent. Houses are 44.3 percent. Hotel and boutique listings are 39.3 percent. Those mixes travel with sixty-one cards. They travel with $24,370. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. ADR is $396. A guest who needs eight beds is common here. Write the house. Photograph the table. Leave out unverified a studio as this market.
Stay is 3.3 nights. Lead is 102 days. Origin is Columbus, then Cleveland. August is the busiest month. The three strongest months are August, July, and June. January is the slowest month. Occupancy is at its lowest in February. Superhost share is 34.4 percent. Professionally managed share is 39.3 percent.Buying a Kelleys Island rentalstill has to underwrite this mix, not a mix-uped Put-in-Bay house. Eight-plus is a share. It is not occupancy. Occupancy is 31.0 percent.
Twenty-nine of those sixty-one cards, 47.5 percent, set a 30-plus night minimum. That setting is not a family month. One-night stays are 27.9 percent. Write the filter the extract printed. Do not convert eight-plus into a filled January. Do not convert six-plus into Put-in-Bay occupancy. Put-in-Bay is 58 listings at $31,131. Port Clinton is 215 listings at $20,757. Never average those years into this capacity story. Publish 34.4 percent eight-plus. Publish $24,370. Cite occupancy 31.0 percent. Cite stay 3.3. Cite Columbus origin. Leave Put-in-Bay labeled.
Photos That Match the Guest Who Typed Kelleys Island
The guest typed Kelleys Island. Photograph Kelleys Island. Photograph the grooves you can name. Photograph the village ferry from Marblehead. Photograph State Park as visitor, not as a filled month. Photograph Alvar and Inscription Rock as landscape. Do not paste a Put-in-Bay nightlife gallery. Do not paste a Port Clinton mainland pier as this driveway. Typical year is $24,370. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. ADR is $396. 61 listings. Those figures already include the house the guest will book.
The three strongest months are August, July, and June. August is the busiest month. January is the slowest month. Occupancy is at its lowest in February. Origin is Columbus, then Cleveland. Stay is 3.3 nights. Lead is 102 days.How to market a Kelleys Island staystill has to name the ferry as landscape, not occupancy. A gallery that files a Bass Island caption on a Kelleys listing will lose that guest before the grooves are named. Write the island you can walk.
Entire homes are 62.3 percent. Houses are 44.3 percent. Eight-plus capacity is 34.4 percent. Six-plus is 60.7 percent. Superhost share is 34.4 percent. Professionally managed share is 39.3 percent. Lauren At KI holds 20. Corrie holds 7. Keep those rows in the file. Do not let them rewrite the gallery. Village Transient Rental still sits at. AirROI's low-regulation Keep is a scrape. Live stack is village Transient Rental. Photograph the parcel the desk actually has. Leave AirDNA one hundred twenty-two off the tile. Cite $24,370. Cite 61 listings. Cite August as the peak month. Cite Columbus, then Cleveland. Photograph the island the guest typed.
Put-in-Bay Guests Are a Different Hall
Put-in-Bay guests booked another island. Put-in-Bay published $31,131 on 58 listings. ADR $462. Occupancy 36.5 percent. RevPAR $170. Peak-3 there is August, June, and July. August is the busiest month. Hole there is November. Occupancy low there is March. Lead there is 86 days. Keep those facts. Never average them into Kelleys Island. Typical listings here earned about $24,370 last year from 61 active rentals. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. ADR is $396. Origin here is Columbus, then Cleveland. Stay here is 3.3. Lead here is 102.
A listing that borrows Put-in-Bay language is already wrong. A buyer memo that blends $31,131 into $24,370 is already wrong. One shared lake is not this island.Kelleys Island versus Put-in-Bayexists so those identities stay apart.Village versus Put-in-Bay desksstill split the halls. Serve the guest who typed Kelleys. Leave Bass Island nightlife on the other hall. Leave Port Clinton $20,757 on the mainland.
Port Clinton hole is December. Put-in-Bay hole is November. This hole is January. Occupancy low here is February. Peak-3 here is August, July, and June. Those calendars do not cancel. Year over year here is minus 32.6 percent. Supply here grew 19.6 percent. Treat this as a watch-sized sample. Do not steal 58 listings as this count. Do not steal 215 listings as this count. Publish 61. Publish $24,370. Keep Put-in-Bay guests on their separate market. Cite $24,370. Cite 61 listings. Cite January as this hole. Never average $31,131. Leave Bass Island guests on their hall.
Who this listing Fits
This market fits a guest who typed Kelleys Island. It fits an August peak, a July money month, and a June peak-3 stay. It fits Columbus origin, then Cleveland. It fits a 3.3 night stay and a 102 day lead. It fits 34.4 percent eight-plus houses and 60.7 percent six-plus houses. It fits entire homes at 62.3 percent. Typical year is $24,370 on 61 listings. Occupancy is 31.0 percent. ADR is $396. RevPAR is $133. Those rows are enough.
This market does not fit a mix-uped Put-in-Bay overnight. It does not fit Port Clinton mainland occupancy. It does not fit AirDNA one hundred twenty-two. It does not fit November as this hole. It does not fit a 30-plus filter as occupancy. Twenty-nine cards, 47.5 percent, set that minimum.Remote staysstill have to write the desk if the house has one. They do not convert a min setting into a filled month. January is the slowest month. Occupancy is at its lowest in February.
Village Transient Rental remains $600 at. Erie County lodging remains 4 percent. AirROI's low-regulation Keep remains a scrape. Superhost share is 34.4 percent. Professionally managed share is 39.3 percent. Lauren At KI holds 20. Corrie holds 7. Year over year is minus 32.6 percent. Supply grew 19.6 percent. Treat this as a watch-sized sample. Photograph the grooves. Name the ferry. Cite $24,370. Leave Put-in-Bay $31,131 labeled. Serve the guest who typed this island. Cite occupancy 31.0 percent. Cite ADR $396. Cite stay 3.3. Cite lead 102. Cite August, July, June as peak-3.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who books a Kelleys Island rental in August?
August is the peak month on this market, with August, July, and June forming the three strongest months. Kelleys Island, Ohio published a typical year of $24,370 across 61 listings for the August 2025 through July 2026 vintage, updated 2026-08-08, with Columbus as the top origin market and Cleveland second.
Is June a real part of the peak season here?
Yes. June sits alongside August and July as one of the three strongest months, not a separate slow shoulder period. Price the month the data actually names rather than treating June as pre-season filler ahead of a July-August rush.
Where do most Kelleys Island guests come from?
Columbus is the top origin, with Cleveland as a real second origin, not the product itself. Write copy for the guest who typed "Kelleys Island" specifically rather than leading with either origin city's name.
Is Cleveland the market I should write my listing for?
No. Cleveland is a real second origin city, useful context for retargeting and timing, but the island itself is the product. Keep the two facts separate: where a booking started, and what the guest actually searched for and chose.
How common is eight-plus guest capacity on Kelleys Island?
Eight-plus capacity shows up in 34.4 percent of listings on this 61-listing market, three-plus bedrooms are 39.4 percent, and entire-home listings are 62.3 percent. That's a capacity share, not an occupancy figure, so don't treat a large house as automatically translating into a filled January calendar.
What photos match the guest who's actually searching for Kelleys Island?
Photograph what's genuinely on the island: the glacial grooves, the village ferry landing from Marblehead, the State Park, Alvar, and Inscription Rock. Don't use a Put-in-Bay nightlife shot or a Port Clinton mainland pier photo to stand in for this driveway; a guest who booked the island expects the island.
Are Put-in-Bay guests part of the Kelleys Island market?
No, they booked a different island entirely. Put-in-Bay published $31,131 across 58 listings with 36.5 percent occupancy, compared to Kelleys Island's $24,370 across 61 listings with Columbus, then Cleveland, as its own origin mix. Keep the two islands' figures on separate lines rather than blending them into one market story.
What does a 30-night-plus minimum-stay setting actually mean here?
It reflects a listing configuration, not proof of booked demand. Twenty-nine listings, or 47.5 percent of this market, are set up to accept a 30-plus night minimum, which is a filter choice hosts made, not an occupancy statistic you can cite as evidence of long-stay bookings.
Who does the Kelleys Island rental market fit best?
It fits a host willing to serve the guest who specifically typed "Kelleys Island" into search, for an August peak, a strong July, or a June that belongs in the peak-three, rather than a host trying to borrow Put-in-Bay's nightlife reputation or occupancy numbers for a different island.
Related Reading
More Kelleys Island, Ohio reading already live on Crest & Cove.
Work with Crest & Cove Creative
Kelleys Island listings that borrow a Put-in-Bay caption or average in Cleveland nightlife are describing a different island's overnight. The grooves, the village ferry, and the Columbus-then-Cleveland origin mix belong to this parcel alone.
We help Kelleys Island hosts keep Put-in-Bay's numbers and captions off their own listing. Send your live draft and we will flag any line that could describe a Bass Island stay instead of yours.
Reach out at crestcove.co or (256) 998-7502.
Comments